Chemistry: An Overview — Question 1

Section 1-1 · Chemistry pages 7–8

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

A disappearing solid is not disappearing matter

A sealed transparent vessel contains water and a soluble white solid. After shaking, the solid is no longer visible, the liquid is clear, and the mass of the sealed vessel is unchanged.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Distinguish two direct observations from one particle-level interpretation.

  2. A student says, The solid has ceased to exist. Explain why the observations do not support this claim.

  3. Propose a recovery test and state what its result would establish.

Question 1 - Solution

A disappearing solid is not disappearing matter

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Observation and model

No visible solid remains and the measured total mass is unchanged. A particle-level interpretation is that particles originating in the solid have dispersed throughout the water; particles themselves were not directly observed.

(b) Evaluate the claim

Invisibility does not imply absence. The unchanged mass is consistent with matter remaining in the vessel. These observations alone do not establish whether the original substance remains chemically unchanged.

(c) Test the interpretation

Evaporate the solvent from a separate sample under suitable conditions and examine any residue. Recovery of a residue supports the presence of nonvolatile matter in the clear liquid. Identifying it as the original substance requires comparing properties; residue alone does not prove identity.

Check and interpretation

Keep observation, explanatory model, and a test of identity separate.