Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Three languages for the same water sample
A student writes: (i) Droplets form on a cold surface; (ii) Water is represented as ; (iii) Water molecules move closer together as vapor condenses.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Classify each statement as macroscopic, symbolic, or particle-level.
What does the subscript 2 specify, and what does it not specify?
A student draws condensed water as separate H and O atoms. Explain the flaw.
Question 4 - Solution
Three languages for the same water sample
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Identify representations
(i) Macroscopic: droplets can be observed. (ii) Symbolic: the formula summarizes composition. (iii) Particle-level: a model describes molecular arrangement.
(b) Read the formula
The subscript specifies two hydrogen atoms per water molecule; the implicit oxygen subscript is one. It does not specify the number of molecules in a droplet, their speed, or the physical state.
(c) Preserve molecular identity
Ordinary condensation changes intermolecular spacing and organization without breaking each water molecule into atoms. Draw intact water molecules closer together, not isolated elemental atoms.
Check and interpretation
A physical change can alter arrangement while preserving molecular composition.