Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Color change: evidence, not an automatic verdict
A blue liquid becomes pale when water is added. A different blue liquid turns green when a reagent is added. No other measurements are available.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Give a physical explanation for the first observation.
Explain why the second color change alone does not prove a chemical reaction.
Propose an additional comparison that would strengthen a chemical-change interpretation.
Question 6 - Solution
Color change: evidence, not an automatic verdict
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Explain dilution
Adding water can spread the same amount of colored material through a larger volume, making the color paler without creating a new substance.
(b) Limit the inference
An added colored reagent can produce a green appearance by mixing colors. Changes in concentration or viewing conditions can also alter appearance. Color is evidence to investigate, not a uniquely diagnostic test.
(c) Seek discriminating evidence
Compare the mixture with the separately diluted components under identical viewing conditions. Evidence for a newly formed substance, such as isolation of a product with distinct properties, would strengthen the reaction interpretation beyond color alone.
Check and interpretation
A plausible alternative explanation must be considered before assigning a mechanism.