Chemistry: An Overview — Question 9

Section 1-1 · Chemistry pages 23–24

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Does cutting a sample change what it is?

A homogeneous metal block of mass 60.0 g is cut into three pieces without losing material. A student argues that each piece is a new substance because its mass and shape differ from the original block.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain the error in this argument.

  2. If one piece has mass 14.0 g and another 21.0 g, determine the third mass.

  3. Suggest a property-based comparison that would test whether the pieces are the same material.

Question 9 - Solution

Does cutting a sample change what it is?

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Distinguish amount from identity

Mass and shape depend on the size and geometry of a sample. Changing them by cutting does not by itself change chemical identity.

(b) Conserve the total

m3=60.0−14.0−21.0=25.0g.m_3=60.0-14.0-21.0=\boxed{25.0\ \mathrm g}.The three masses sum to the starting mass.

(c) Compare under common conditions

Compare density at the same temperature or composition using the same analysis. Equal characteristic properties support the same material identity; a single matching property alone need not uniquely identify the metal.

Check and interpretation

Physical subdivision conserves material even though each piece has different sample-dependent properties.