The Scientific Method — Question 6

Section 1-2 · Chemistry pages 37–38

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Use a graph to question a claimed trend

The graph shows hypothetical mean product amounts collected after 10 minutes at three temperatures. Vertical bars are stated bounds, not statistical confidence intervals.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Read the three mean amounts and describe the pattern.

  2. Does the graph support the claim that increasing temperature always increases the amount collected?

  3. Propose two follow-up temperatures and one experimental control.

Question 6 - Solution

Use a graph to question a claimed trend

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Read the data

The means are 4, 8 and 5 mg at 20, 40 and 60∘C60^\circ\mathrm C, respectively. The amount first rises and then falls.

(b) Evaluate the universal claim

No. The decrease from 40 to 60∘C60^\circ\mathrm C contradicts a monotonic increase over these tested conditions; the bounds at these points do not overlap. The data do not establish the mechanism of the decrease.

(c) Refine the investigation

Test 30 and 50∘C50^\circ\mathrm C to resolve the trend near the apparent maximum. Keep collection time, starting amounts and collection efficiency controlled. Check for loss of collected material at higher temperatures.

Check and interpretation

The largest observed value is not proof of the exact optimum temperature.