Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
A law and a theory answer different questions
A repeated experiment establishes that total mass is unchanged in a closed vessel within measurement uncertainty. A particle model explains this by rearrangement of conserved atoms.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which statement describes an empirical regularity and which offers an explanation?
Explain why a well-supported theory does not simply become a law after enough tests.
If a later trial shows a small mass decrease, identify two checks before abandoning the model.
Question 7 - Solution
A law and a theory answer different questions
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Distinguish roles
The mass relationship is an empirical regularity that can be expressed as a law within its domain. The conserved-atom model offers an explanatory account of that relationship.
(b) Avoid a hierarchy
Laws summarize relationships; theories provide explanatory frameworks. Additional support strengthens confidence in a theory but does not change its explanatory role into a different category.
(c) Investigate discrepancies
Check vessel leakage or escape during handling, and check balance calibration or environmental effects on the reading. Compare the decrease with measurement uncertainty and repeat under controlled conditions.
Check and interpretation
Discrepant evidence matters, but both the experiment and the model assumptions must be examined.