The Scientific Method — Question 9

Section 1-2 · Chemistry pages 43–44

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Correlation does not identify the cause

Across six storage rooms, containers in brighter rooms show more color fading. Brighter rooms are also warmer. A report concludes that light caused the fading.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the alternative explanation.

  2. Design a four-condition experiment separating light from temperature.

  3. Explain what comparison estimates the light effect at a fixed temperature.

Question 9 - Solution

Correlation does not identify the cause

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Identify the confounder

Temperature covaries with light, so higher temperature could account for some or all of the fading. The observational comparison cannot separate their effects.

(b) Cross the factors

Use bright/cool, dark/cool, bright/warm and dark/warm conditions. Randomly allocate comparable samples, repeat each condition, and keep storage time and container composition fixed.

(c) Compare within temperature

Compare bright/cool with dark/cool, then bright/warm with dark/warm. If the light effect differs between temperatures, report that dependence rather than assuming one universal light effect.

Check and interpretation

A controlled design can reveal both separate effects and interactions between factors.