Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Use units to audit a proposed formula
A cylindrical vessel has cross-sectional area in and liquid depth in m. Its radius is in m. Three proposed volume formulas are , , and . Take to be dimensionless.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Determine which expression has volume units and explain why the other two fail.
For and , calculate the volume using the unit-consistent expression.
Would the alternative formula pass a unit check? Does that make it geometrically correct?
Question 7 - Solution
Use units to audit a proposed formula
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Check operations and powers
The sum tries to add area and length, which are different kinds of quantity. Also, , an area unit rather than a volume unit.
(b) Calculate the volume
A cylinder of constant cross section has volume equal to its cross-sectional area multiplied by depth.
(c) Recognize the limit of the test
The number 2 is dimensionless, so also has units . It nevertheless gives twice the correct volume for this geometry. Unit consistency is necessary, but it cannot determine a dimensionless numerical coefficient.
Check and interpretation
Units can reject an impossible expression without proving every expression that survives the check.