Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 2

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 69–70

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

A stable digital display is not a perfect measurement

A balance displays 5.24 g in increments of 0.01 g. Its display rounds to the nearest increment. A separate specification gives an overall error bound of ±0.03\pm0.03 g under the present conditions; this bound already includes display rounding. Four repeated displays all read 5.24 g.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. What is the largest possible rounding error from the display increment alone?

  2. Give the mass interval using the overall specification. Should the rounding bound be added again?

  3. Do identical displays prove zero uncertainty or exact accuracy?

Question 2 - Solution

A stable digital display is not a perfect measurement

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Identify the rounding scale

Rounding to the nearest 0.01 g can change the indicated value by at most half an increment:|eround|≤0.012=0.005g.|e_{\mathrm{round}}|\leq\frac{0.01}{2}=0.005\ \mathrm g.This describes rounding alone, not all instrument errors.

(b) Use the overall bound once

m∈[5.24−0.03,5.24+0.03]=[5.21,5.27]g.m\in[5.24-0.03,5.24+0.03]=\boxed{[5.21,5.27]\ \mathrm g}.Do not add 0.005 g again because the supplied overall specification already includes rounding. Doing so would count that contribution twice.

(c) Interpret identical readings

Identical displays show no variation at the displayed resolution in these four trials. Smaller fluctuations can be hidden by rounding, and a calibration bias can affect every reading alike. Neither zero uncertainty nor exact agreement with the true mass follows.

Check and interpretation

Resolution, repeatability and accuracy describe different aspects of a measurement.