Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 3

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 71–72

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Separate precision from agreement with a reference

Two balances measure a reference mass assigned 10.00 g; treat reference uncertainty as negligible here. Balance A reads 10.18, 10.20 and 10.22 g. Balance B reads 9.90, 10.00 and 10.10 g. Use the range, maximum minus minimum, as a simple measure of scatter.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate each mean and range. Which set is more precise on this measure?

  2. Calculate each mean's signed deviation from the reference. Which mean agrees better?

  3. Explain why the results do not identify one balance as universally superior.

Question 3 - Solution

Separate precision from agreement with a reference

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Compare scatter

m¯A=10.20g,RA=10.22−10.18=0.04g,\overline m_A=10.20\ \mathrm g,\quad R_A=10.22-10.18=0.04\ \mathrm g,m¯B=10.00g,RB=10.10−9.90=0.20g.\overline m_B=10.00\ \mathrm g,\quad R_B=10.10-9.90=0.20\ \mathrm g.A has the smaller range and is more precise in these trials.

(b) Compare mean deviations

bA=10.20−10.00=+0.20g,bB=10.00−10.00=0.00g.b_A=10.20-10.00=+0.20\ \mathrm g,\qquad b_B=10.00-10.00=0.00\ \mathrm g.B's mean agrees better with the reference. A's tightly grouped values suggest a positive bias at this mass.

(c) State the limits

These three readings concern one reference and one set of conditions. They do not establish long-term performance or performance at other masses. A might improve with calibration, while B has more scatter. Additional references and repeated trials are needed.

Check and interpretation

A small range does not guarantee a small bias; a mean that matches a reference does not imply every reading is accurate.