Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 5

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 75–76

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Overlapping bounds permit agreement but do not prove equality

Two laboratories measure separate aliquots intended to have equal volumes: VA=(25.00±0.04)V_A=(25.00\pm0.04) mL and VB=(25.05±0.03)V_B=(25.05\pm0.03) mL. Treat the plus/minus values as inclusive bounds, not standard deviations. No relationship between the two errors is known.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Write both intervals and find their overlap, if any.

  2. Determine the full possible interval for VB−VAV_B-V_A under these bounds.

  3. Can you conclude that B's volume is definitely greater, that the volumes are exactly equal, or that the results are compatible?

Question 5 - Solution

Overlapping bounds permit agreement but do not prove equality

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Compare intervals

VA∈[24.96,25.04],VB∈[25.02,25.08]mL.V_A\in[24.96,25.04],\qquad V_B\in[25.02,25.08]\quad\mathrm{mL}.The common interval is [25.02,25.04]mL\boxed{[25.02,25.04]\ \mathrm{mL}}.

(b) Use the extreme combinations

(VB−VA)min=25.02−25.04=−0.02mL,(V_B-V_A)_{\min}=25.02-25.04=-0.02\ \mathrm{mL},(VB−VA)max=25.08−24.96=0.12mL.(V_B-V_A)_{\max}=25.08-24.96=0.12\ \mathrm{mL}.Thus the difference lies in [−0.02,0.12][-0.02,0.12] mL, equivalently 0.05±0.070.05\pm0.07 mL as a bound.

(c) Limit the conclusion

The interval includes zero and both signs, so a definitely positive difference is not established. Equality is allowed but not proven. The reports are compatible with a common volume in the overlap. These deterministic bounds do not provide a statistical significance test.

Check and interpretation

The difference bound has half-width 0.04+0.03=0.070.04+0.03=0.07 mL; it is not obtained by subtracting the two uncertainty magnitudes.