Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 7

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 79–80

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Subtract readings carefully: reading errors and a common offset

A burette indicates an initial volume of 5.12 mL and a final volume of 32.46 mL. Each reading has a bounded reading error of at most 0.03 mL; no relationship between those reading errors is known. In addition, suppose the same additive calibration offset cc affects both indications. The delivered volume is final minus initial.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the indicated delivered volume.

  2. Find its conservative reading-error bound by considering the largest and smallest possible differences.

  3. Show algebraically whether the common offset cc affects the difference. Would the same conclusion hold for a multiplicative scale error?

Question 7 - Solution

Subtract readings carefully: reading errors and a common offset

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Take the difference

ΔV=32.46−5.12=27.34mL.\Delta V=32.46-5.12=\boxed{27.34\ \mathrm{mL}}.The indicated values must be subtracted in final-minus-initial order.

(b) Combine bounded reading errors

ΔVmin=(32.46−0.03)−(5.12+0.03)=27.28mL,\Delta V_{\min}=(32.46-0.03)-(5.12+0.03)=27.28\ \mathrm{mL},ΔVmax=(32.46+0.03)−(5.12−0.03)=27.40mL.\Delta V_{\max}=(32.46+0.03)-(5.12-0.03)=27.40\ \mathrm{mL}.The conservative result is 27.34±0.06mL\boxed{27.34\pm0.06\ \mathrm{mL}}. Opposite-sign endpoint errors maximize the error in the difference.

(c) Identify what cancels

(Vf+c)−(Vi+c)=Vf−Vi.(V_f+c)-(V_i+c)=V_f-V_i.An identical additive offset cancels. If both indications instead have a factor kk, then kVf−kVi=k(Vf−Vi)kV_f-kV_i=k(V_f-V_i), so the factor remains. Cancellation requires the stated shared-offset model; it is not a property of all calibration errors.

Check and interpretation

The common offset cancels, but unrelated reading errors need not. Their worst-case magnitudes add in a difference.