Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 9

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 83–84

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Averaging viewing errors is not a reading protocol

Three observers read the same stationary concave meniscus. One looks from above and reports 18.9 mL; another looks at meniscus level and reports 18.7 mL; the third looks from below and reports 18.5 mL. The cylinder is upright. Assume the bottom of the meniscus is the intended reading point.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which viewing position follows the correct procedure, and why?

  2. Calculate the mean of the three readings. Does its agreement with the level-view reading validate averaging arbitrary viewing positions?

  3. Give a repeatable reading protocol and name an uncertainty source it does not remove.

Question 9 - Solution

Averaging viewing errors is not a reading protocol

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Align the line of sight

The level-view observer follows the intended procedure. Viewing at meniscus level aligns the bottom of the curved surface with the scale and minimizes parallax caused by viewing a surface and scale at different depths from an oblique angle.

(b) Recognize an accidental cancellation

V¯=18.9+18.7+18.53=18.7mL.\overline V=\frac{18.9+18.7+18.5}{3}=18.7\ \mathrm{mL}.The offsets in this example happen to be symmetric. Arbitrary viewing errors need not be equal and opposite, so averaging them is not a justified substitute for a controlled viewing position.

(c) Control the procedure

Place the cylinder upright on a level surface, allow the liquid to settle, and read the bottom of the meniscus with the eye at its height under consistent lighting. Repeat that procedure. Calibration error and finite scale resolution can remain even after parallax is minimized.

Check and interpretation

The given above/below readings describe this setup; do not assume their signs or symmetry are universal for all instruments.