Significant Figures and Calculations — Question 2

Section 1-5 · Chemistry pages 89–90

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Make a terminal-zero record unambiguous

A mass record says only 1500 g, with no precision note. The original instrument record is unavailable. Three possible intentions are rounding to the nearest 100 g, nearest 10 g, or nearest 1 g. Assume each intention would make the last reported digit significant.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Write 1500 g in scientific notation for each of those three intentions, and count its significant figures.

  2. Explain why the original record cannot establish which intention was used.

  3. Would rewriting every such record as 1.500×1031.500\times10^3 g repair the missing information?

Question 2 - Solution

Make a terminal-zero record unambiguous

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Encode the intended last place

Nearest 100 g:1.5×103g(2 figures),Nearest 10 g:1.50×103g(3 figures),Nearest 1 g:1.500×103g(4 figures).\begin{aligned}\text{Nearest 100 g:}&\quad1.5\times10^3\ \mathrm g&&\text{(2 figures)},\\\text{Nearest 10 g:}&\quad1.50\times10^3\ \mathrm g&&\text{(3 figures)},\\\text{Nearest 1 g:}&\quad1.500\times10^3\ \mathrm g&&\text{(4 figures)}.\end{aligned}The coefficient makes the retained zeros explicit.

(b) Identify the ambiguity

All three expressions have numerical value 1500 g. Terminal zeros in a whole-number record without a precision convention do not, by themselves, reveal the intended last significant place. One must consult the original method or recording convention.

(c) Do not invent precision

No. Writing four significant figures would assert detail that may never have been measured. Recover the missing precision information if possible, or explicitly mark it as unspecified. A typographical change cannot reconstruct an unavailable measurement record.

Check and interpretation

Scientific notation can communicate known precision clearly; it cannot supply precision that was never documented.