Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Addition is limited by decimal place, not digit count
Three measured portions of a solid have masses 12.11 g, 0.3 g and 1.006 g. They are combined without loss. Use the introductory addition rule: round the sum to the coarsest decimal place among the inputs.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the unrounded sum and report the total mass appropriately.
A student rounds the sum to one significant figure because 0.3 has one significant figure. Explain why that rule is inappropriate here.
If the middle mass had instead been recorded as 0.300 g, what total would be reported?
Question 3 - Solution
Addition is limited by decimal place, not digit count
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Apply the addition rule
The coarsest input place is tenths of a gram, soRetain the raw sum until the reporting step.
(b) Use the correct operation rule
The conventional addition rule compares absolute decimal places. It does not take the smallest count of significant figures. Rounding to one significant figure would give g and discard more information than this rule requires.
(c) Reassess the limiting place
The raw sum is still 13.416 g. With 0.300 g, the coarsest place is now the hundredths place in 12.11 g, so the report is . The trailing zeros in 0.300 are meaningful here.
Check and interpretation
The two reports differ because the stated input precision changed, not because the underlying numerical sum changed.