Significant Figures and Calculations — Question 8

Section 1-5 · Chemistry pages 101–102

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Premature rounding can change the final answer

A corrected mass is defined by mcorr=k(mf−mi)m_{\mathrm{corr}}=k(m_f-m_i), where the measured values are mf=12.11m_f=12.11 g, mi=12.0m_i=12.0 g and dimensionless k=3.45k=3.45. Use the usual decimal-place rule for subtraction and significant-figure rule for multiplication. Keep unrounded intermediate values while tracking the precision limit.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compute the unrounded mass difference and identify its limiting decimal place.

  2. Calculate the corrected mass with guard digits, then report the final result at the precision implied by the intermediate difference.

  3. Calculate what happens if the difference is rounded before multiplication. Explain why that final answer differs.

Question 8 - Solution

Premature rounding can change the final answer

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Track precision without discarding digits

mf−mi=12.11−12.0=0.11g.m_f-m_i=12.11-12.0=0.11\ \mathrm g.The subtraction is limited to tenths of a gram by 12.0 g. If reported alone it would be 0.1 g, with one significant figure. Keep 0.11 internally while carrying that precision limit.

(b) Round only the final result

mcorr=3.45(0.11)=0.3795g.m_{\mathrm{corr}}=3.45(0.11)=0.3795\ \mathrm g.The intermediate difference, not the three-figure factor, limits the final report to one significant figure:mcorr=0.4g.\boxed{m_{\mathrm{corr}}=0.4\ \mathrm g}.This uses the specified introductory significant-figure convention.

(c) Identify the double-rounding effect

Rounding the difference first gives 3.45(0.1)=0.3453.45(0.1)=0.345 g, which rounds to 0.3 g at one significant figure. The premature rounding moved the result across the final rounding boundary. Guard digits avoid that avoidable numerical change; they do not claim extra measurement precision.

Check and interpretation

Significant-figure rules are reporting heuristics, not a full uncertainty calculation. Keep arithmetic precision separate from final reporting precision.