Dimensional Analysis — Question 8

Section 1-6 · Chemistry pages 121–122

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

An inverse-length unit reverses the conversion intuition

A model uses q=αLq=\alpha L, where qq is dimensionless, LL is a length, and the measured coefficient is α=0.0750mm−1\alpha=0.0750\ \mathrm{mm^{-1}}. Use exactly 1m=1000mm1\ \mathrm m=1000\ \mathrm{mm} and 1cm=10mm1\ \mathrm{cm}=10\ \mathrm{mm}. No particular physical interpretation of qq is needed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Express α\alpha in m−1\mathrm{m^{-1}}, showing the unit cancellation.

  2. Calculate qq for L=2.00L=2.00 cm in two consistent unit systems.

  3. Calculate the characteristic length 1/α1/\alpha in mm and m. Explain why inverse-length coefficients and lengths convert in opposite numerical directions.

Question 8 - Solution

An inverse-length unit reverses the conversion intuition

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Convert a denominator unit

α=0.0750mm1000mm1m=75.0m−1.\alpha=\frac{0.0750}{\mathrm{mm}}\,\frac{1000\ \mathrm{mm}}{1\ \mathrm m}=\boxed{75.0\ \mathrm{m^{-1}}}.The millimeter is in the denominator, so the conversion factor must put millimeters in the numerator.

(b) Keep the product invariant

q=(0.0750mm−1)(20.0mm)=1.50,q=(0.0750\ \mathrm{mm^{-1}})(20.0\ \mathrm{mm})=\boxed{1.50},q=(75.0m−1)(0.0200m)=1.50.q=(75.0\ \mathrm{m^{-1}})(0.0200\ \mathrm m)=1.50.In both routes the length units cancel completely.

(c) Take a reciprocal length scale

1α=10.0750mm=13.333…mm→13.3mm.\frac1\alpha=\frac1{0.0750}\ \mathrm{mm}=13.333\ldots\ \mathrm{mm}\longrightarrow\boxed{13.3\ \mathrm{mm}}.1α=0.013333…m→0.0133m.\frac1\alpha=0.013333\ldots\ \mathrm m\longrightarrow\boxed{0.0133\ \mathrm m}.A longer reference unit requires fewer units to express a length, but more inverse-length units in the coefficient so that αL\alpha L remains unchanged.

Check and interpretation

The reciprocal of 75.0m−175.0\ \mathrm{m^{-1}} agrees with the meter result; the dimensionless product is independent of the chosen length unit.