Dimensional Analysis — Question 10

Section 1-6 · Chemistry pages 125–126

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Audit a software interface that silently changes units

A sensor reports a measured liquid delivery rate of 2.40 mL/s. A logging program expects a numerical entry in L/min and treats whatever number it receives as having that unit. The number 2.40 is transmitted unchanged. Use exactly 1000 mL per L and 60 s per min.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the correct numerical entry for the program.

  2. Find the ratio of the interpreted rate to the intended rate, using a common unit.

  3. For a measured 5.00 min run, compare the volume predicted by the unchanged entry with the correct volume, and propose one interface check.

Question 10 - Solution

Audit a software interface that silently changes units

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Convert the full rate

Q=2.40mLs1L1000mL60s1min=0.144L/min.Q=2.40\ \frac{\mathrm{mL}}{\mathrm s}\,\frac{1\ \mathrm L}{1000\ \mathrm{mL}}\,\frac{60\ \mathrm s}{1\ \mathrm{min}}=\boxed{0.144\ \mathrm{L/min}}.The number to enter in the program's L/min field is 0.144.

(b) Compare like units

The unchanged entry is interpreted as 2.40 L/min. HenceQinterpretedQintended=2.400.144=16.666…≈16.7.\frac{Q_{\mathrm{interpreted}}}{Q_{\mathrm{intended}}}=\frac{2.40}{0.144}=16.666\ldots\approx\boxed{16.7}.The software interprets a rate about 16.7 times too large.

(c) Check an accumulated consequence

Vwrong=(2.40L/min)(5.00min)=12.0L,V_{\mathrm{wrong}}=(2.40\ \mathrm{L/min})(5.00\ \mathrm{min})=12.0\ \mathrm L,Vcorrect=(0.144L/min)(5.00min)=0.720L.V_{\mathrm{correct}}=(0.144\ \mathrm{L/min})(5.00\ \mathrm{min})=\boxed{0.720\ \mathrm L}.Transmit the numerical value together with an explicit unit, and verify the conversion with a known test rate before accepting data. The unchanged number alone cannot specify the physical rate.

Check and interpretation

Rate and time units cancel to give volume. The same factor-of-16.7 discrepancy appears in both rates and accumulated volumes.