Temperature — Question 3

Section 1-7 · Chemistry pages 131–132

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Twice the Celsius reading is not twice the absolute temperature

Sample A is at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\mathrm C and sample B is at 40.0∘C40.0^\circ\mathrm C. Use TK=tC+273.15T_K=t_C+273.15 exactly. For temperature ratios, use absolute temperature in kelvins. Carry unrounded converted values through calculations; round exact halfway cases upward.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find TB/TAT_B/T_A and report the ratio to four significant figures.

  2. Find the Celsius temperature that corresponds to twice A's absolute temperature. Report it to 0.1 degree.

  3. Explain why the numerical Celsius ratio 40.0/20.040.0/20.0 cannot answer part (a).

Question 3 - Solution

Twice the Celsius reading is not twice the absolute temperature

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Form an absolute-scale ratio

TA=293.15K,TB=313.15K.T_A=293.15\ \mathrm K,\qquad T_B=313.15\ \mathrm K.TBTA=313.15293.15=1.068224…→1.068.\frac{T_B}{T_A}=\frac{313.15}{293.15}=1.068224\ldots\longrightarrow\boxed{1.068}.B's absolute temperature is only about 6.8% higher, not twice A's.

(b) Double before changing the zero point

Ttarget=2(293.15)=586.30K.T_{\mathrm{target}}=2(293.15)=586.30\ \mathrm K.tC,target=586.30−273.15=313.15∘C→313.2∘C.t_{C,\mathrm{target}}=586.30-273.15=313.15^\circ\mathrm C\longrightarrow\boxed{313.2^\circ\mathrm C}.For the final halfway rounding case, use rounding upward.

(c) Recognize an offset scale

Celsius zero is not absolute zero. Adding a fixed offset changes ratios: 40/2040/20 is not (40+273.15)/(20+273.15)(40+273.15)/(20+273.15). Thermodynamic temperature ratios require an absolute scale; Celsius values remain appropriate for temperatures and temperature differences when used correctly.

Check and interpretation

Doubling an absolute temperature must produce a temperature much higher than a mere increase from 20 to 40∘C40^\circ\mathrm C.