Density — Question 8

Section 1-8 · Chemistry pages 161–162

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Bound a density before identifying a sample

A sample has mass (25.0±0.1)(25.0\pm0.1) g and volume (10.0±0.2)(10.0\pm0.2) mL. Treat these as inclusive bounds with every combination in the two intervals possible. Two candidate reference densities, treated as exact here, are P: 2.45 and Q: 2.60g/mL2.60\ \mathrm{g/mL}.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the lowest and highest possible densities. Give bounds rounded outward to three decimal places.

  2. Which candidates are compatible with the measurements? Does compatibility establish identity?

  3. With the mass bounds unchanged, a better volume measurement gives (10.00±0.05)(10.00\pm0.05) mL. Determine whether P remains compatible.

Question 8 - Solution

Bound a density before identifying a sample

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Combine the extreme ratios

For positive mass and volume, the smallest ratio uses the smallest mass and largest volume:ρmin=24.910.2=2.441176…,ρmax=25.19.8=2.561224….\rho_{\min}=\frac{24.9}{10.2}=2.441176\ldots,\quad\rho_{\max}=\frac{25.1}{9.8}=2.561224\ldots.Outward rounding gives [2.441,2.562]g/mL\boxed{[2.441,2.562]\ \mathrm{g/mL}}, enclosing the exact interval.

(b) Test the reference values

P, 2.45, lies inside the allowed interval; Q, 2.60, lies outside. Only P is compatible among these two candidates. Compatibility does not prove identity; other materials may share the density.

(c) Use the narrower volume interval

ρmin=24.910.05=2.477611…,ρmax=25.19.95=2.522613….\rho_{\min}=\frac{24.9}{10.05}=2.477611\ldots,\quad\rho_{\max}=\frac{25.1}{9.95}=2.522613\ldots.The outward-rounded interval is [2.477,2.523]g/mL[2.477,2.523]\ \mathrm{g/mL}. P is now excluded. Neither listed candidate fits the improved data under the stated assumptions.

Check and interpretation

The nominal ratio 2.50 g/mL lies inside both intervals; better precision can exclude a previously compatible candidate.