Density — Question 10

Section 1-8 · Chemistry pages 165–166

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Design a density measurement for a floating solid

A nonporous solid floats in water, so it is attached to a dense sinker. The cylinder reads 50.0 mL with the sinker alone fully submerged and 62.5 mL with the sinker and solid both fully submerged. The dry solid mass is 9.00 g. Assume negligible thread volume, no bubbles, no dissolution and unchanged sinker displacement.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the solid volume and density to appropriate precision.

  2. Why is the bare-water reading unnecessary? Explain what subtraction removes.

  3. If the sinker touches the cylinder bottom in one reading but remains fully submerged, does that alone invalidate this volume method? Contrast this with a trapped bubble or partial immersion.

Question 10 - Solution

Design a density measurement for a floating solid

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Isolate the added displacement

Vs=62.5−50.0=12.5mL.V_s=62.5-50.0=12.5\ \mathrm{mL}.ρs=9.0012.5=0.720g/mL.\rho_s=\frac{9.00}{12.5}=\boxed{0.720\ \mathrm{g/mL}}.This value is consistent with floating in water of density approximately 1.00 g/mL.

(b) Cancel common contributions

Both readings include the same original water and the same fully submerged sinker displacement. Their difference isolates the solid displacement, so a separate bare-water reading is not needed. Water must not be added or spilled between readings.

(c) Identify which conditions affect displacement

Bottom contact alone does not change the geometric volume occupied by a rigid, fully submerged sinker in this method, assuming no trapped voids or deformation. A bubble adds spurious displaced volume; partial immersion removes some displacement. Either breaks the assumed cancellation or overstates the solid volume.

Check and interpretation

The sinker mass is irrelevant to this displacement subtraction; the solid mass must be measured separately.