Classification of Matter — Question 2

Section 1-9 · Chemistry pages 169–170

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Two phases can still be one pure substance

Consider three closed systems: I contains only pure water as ice and liquid; II contains salt completely dissolved in water as one uniform liquid; III contains separate layers of oil and water, which do not dissolve in each other. A phase is a physically uniform region with distinct boundaries from other phases. Count only the stated condensed phases, ignoring headspace.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Give the number of phases and classify each system as a pure substance, homogeneous mixture or heterogeneous mixture.

  2. Explain why counting visible phases alone cannot distinguish a pure substance from a mixture.

  3. If all ice in I melts without contamination, does its classification as a substance change? What changes in its phase description?

Question 2 - Solution

Two phases can still be one pure substance

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Classify on two separate criteria

I has two phases but is one pure compound, water. II has one phase and is a homogeneous mixture of salt and water. III has two phases and is a heterogeneous mixture.

(b) Separate phase from composition

Phases describe physical regions or states; purity describes chemical composition. The same substance can occupy two phases, as in I. Multiple substances can form a single phase, as in II. A single phase therefore does not prove purity, and two phases do not necessarily prove a mixture.

(c) Describe melting

I remains pure water, a compound. It changes from a two-phase ice–liquid system to a one-phase liquid system. Melting is a physical change: water molecules retain their chemical identity.

Check and interpretation

For I, calling the sample a heterogeneous mixture would incorrectly turn a phase difference into a composition difference.