Classification of Matter — Question 4

Section 1-9 · Chemistry pages 173–174

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Separate three components while preserving their identities

A dry 12.0 g mixture contains 3.0 g of iron filings, 4.0 g of sand and 5.0 g of a water-soluble salt. Only iron is attracted by the available magnet; only the salt dissolves in water. Assume none reacts with water and the salt tolerates gentle water evaporation without decomposition.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Design a sequence that recovers all three components separately, identifying the property used at each step.

  2. After ideal separation and complete drying, what mass of each component and total dry mass should be recovered? Does adding water increase the original dry-component mass?

  3. Explain why filtration of the salt solution alone cannot recover the dissolved salt, and identify a likely cause of a recovered dry total below 12.0 g.

Question 4 - Solution

Separate three components while preserving their identities

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Use selective physical properties

First remove iron magnetically. Add water to dissolve the salt in the remaining sand–salt mixture. Filter to retain sand; wash the sand with a little water and combine the washings with the filtrate. Dry the sand. Gently evaporate water from the filtrate to recover dry salt. These steps use magnetism, solubility, particle retention and volatility.

(b) Track the original components

Ideal dry recoveries are 3.0 g iron, 4.0 g sand and 5.0 g salt, totaling 12.0 g. Added water is a processing solvent; after it is removed it does not increase the mass of the original components.

(c) Identify limitations

Dissolved salt passes through an ordinary filter with water; filtration separates suspended sand, not dissolved salt. A low dry total could result from transfer losses or salt solution discarded before evaporation. A high total could indicate incomplete drying or contamination.

Check and interpretation

No chemical decomposition is needed: each original component is recovered with its identity preserved.