Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
A constant ratio supports a compound but does not prove one
Two samples contain only elements A and B. Analysis gives sample I: 4.00 g A and 6.00 g B; sample II: 8.00 g A and 12.00 g B. The chemical form of each element is initially unknown. Ordinary compounds have a definite elemental composition.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the A mass fraction and A:B mass ratio for each sample. Are the results consistent with one pure compound?
Construct a mixture explanation that reproduces the same results without any A–B chemical bonding.
Later, a validated physical separation recovers elemental A and elemental B from each original sample without a chemical reaction. How does this change the classification?
Question 5 - Solution
A constant ratio supports a compound but does not prove one
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Compare composition
For I, ; for II, . Both have A:B mass ratio . The measurements are consistent with a common pure compound, but consistency is not proof.
(b) Build a countermodel
A preparer could mix separate elemental A and B in a 2:3 mass ratio, using 4.00 and 6.00 g for I and twice those masses for II. Repeating a mixing recipe gives a constant bulk ratio without chemical bonding. A ratio of masses is also not directly an atom-number ratio.
(c) Use the new evidence
The original samples are mixtures of elements under the stated validated separation conditions. Recovery of pre-existing A and B by a physical process contradicts the claim that each original sample was solely an A–B compound. Decomposing a compound into elements would require a chemical change.
Check and interpretation
The same numerical composition can arise from chemical combination or deliberate mixing; the process evidence distinguishes them.