Classification of Matter — Question 7

Section 1-9 · Chemistry pages 179–180

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Classify properties along two independent dimensions

At specified temperature and pressure, a sample is described by four properties: mass, density, melting temperature and ability to react with oxygen. A physical property can be characterized without changing chemical identity; a chemical property describes a possible change in chemical identity. An extensive property depends on amount; an intensive property does not.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Classify the first three properties as physical and either extensive or intensive. Explain how dividing a uniform sample in half affects them.

  2. Classify the ability to react with oxygen as physical or chemical. Why is observing the resulting product different from measuring mass?

  3. A student argues that an intensive property must identify a pure substance uniquely. Give a reason this conclusion does not follow.

Question 7 - Solution

Classify properties along two independent dimensions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Separate amount from identity

Mass is physical and extensive: each equal half has half the original mass. Density and melting temperature are physical and intensive for the same uniform substance at the specified conditions. Dividing the sample does not by itself change these intensive properties. Ignore size-dependent effects in this macroscopic exercise.

(b) Identify a possible chemical transformation

Ability to react with oxygen is a chemical property because it concerns forming substances with different chemical identities. Weighing a sample does not require such a transformation; actually reacting it to observe the product does.

(c) Limit what intensive means

Intensive means independent of sample amount, not unique to one substance or restricted to pure substances. A uniform mixture can have a reproducible density at fixed composition, and different materials can share a similar density. More composition evidence is needed.

Check and interpretation

Physical versus chemical and intensive versus extensive answer different questions about a property.