Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Inventory forces without omitting dispersion
Consider pure CH, HCl and CHOH. CH is nonpolar, HCl has a permanent dipole, and methanol contains an O–H group and oxygen lone pairs. Use the usual introductory hydrogen-bond criterion involving N, O or F.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
List the principal intermolecular interaction types present in each.
Explain why calling methanol hydrogen-bonded does not mean dispersion is absent.
Question 2 - Solution
Inventory forces without omitting dispersion
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
All three have dispersion. HCl also has dipole–dipole interactions. Methanol has dipole–dipole interactions and can form O–H hydrogen bonds.
(b) Analysis
An instantaneous fluctuating electron distribution exists even in a polar molecule. Naming a distinctive interaction does not eliminate other contributions; these categories are a useful description rather than mutually exclusive substances.
Check and interpretation
Ordinary HCl is not classified as a conventional N/O/F hydrogen-bond donor in this introductory scheme.