Intermolecular Forces — Question 7

Section 10-1 · Chemistry pages 1659–1660

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Compare distance dependences

For fixed orientations, use Udipole=−A/r3U_{\mathrm{dipole}}=-A/r^3 for an attractive dipole pair and Udisp=−B/r6U_{\mathrm{disp}}=-B/r^6 for dispersion. A and B are positive constants.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. By what factor does each attraction magnitude change when r doubles?

  2. Why does this not prove which force is larger at a specified distance?

Question 7 - Solution

Compare distance dependences

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The magnitudes become 1/23=1/81/2^3=1/8 and 1/26=1/641/2^6=1/64 of their original values.

(b) Analysis

The prefactors A and B are also required. A steeper decay does not establish the absolute magnitude at a chosen r. The dipole expression assumes a fixed attractive orientation, not a thermal orientation average.

Check and interpretation

Compare dimensionless ratios for the same interaction before comparing unlike prefactors.