Structure and Bonding in Metals — Question 3

Section 10-4 · Chemistry pages 1711–1712

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare ideal packing fractions

Use sphere volume 4πr3/34\pi r^3/3. BCC has two atoms per cell and a=4r/3a=4r/\sqrt3; FCC has four and a=22ra=2\sqrt2r. Packing fraction is occupied sphere volume divided by a3a^3.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive the BCC and FCC packing fractions.

  2. Why does the greater packing fraction not alone prove that an FCC metal has greater density than a BCC metal of another element?

Question 3 - Solution

Compare ideal packing fractions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

BCC gives 2(4πr3/3)/(4r/3)3=π3/8=0.6802(4\pi r^3/3)/(4r/\sqrt3)^3=\pi\sqrt3/8=0.680. FCC gives 4(4πr3/3)/(22r)3=π/(32)=0.7404(4\pi r^3/3)/(2\sqrt2r)^3=\pi/(3\sqrt2)=0.740.

(b) Analysis

Density also depends on atomic mass and radius. Packing fraction compares geometric efficiency of equal-sphere models, not masses of unlike elements.

Check and interpretation

The radius cancels in the dimensionless fraction.