Carbon and Silicon: Network Atomic Solids — Question 10

Section 10-5 · Chemistry pages 1745–1746

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Select a material from structural evidence

A device needs a host whose electrical carrier concentration can be adjusted through small impurity additions. A separate sliding component needs layers that can move relative to each other. Choose between idealized diamond, silicon and graphite using their established structures.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Select a suitable candidate for each role and explain.

  2. State why the chosen structural argument is only a starting point for practical material selection.

Question 10 - Solution

Select a material from structural evidence

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Silicon is a suitable semiconductor host for controlled doping. Graphite provides a layered structure with comparatively easy interlayer sliding.

(b) Analysis

Actual performance depends on purity, defects, processing, temperature and environment. The structural match identifies plausible candidates but does not guarantee a particular device lifetime or friction coefficient.

Check and interpretation

Use the property needed for the role rather than ranking materials by a single word such as strong.