Molecular Solids — Question 3

Section 10-6 · Chemistry pages 1751–1752

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Count shared hydrogen bonds in ideal ice

An ideal periodic ice network contains 1200 intact water molecules. Each water donates two hydrogen bonds and accepts two; there are no defects or surface molecules.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count distinct hydrogen bonds in two different ways.

  2. Explain why this extended hydrogen-bond network is still classified as a molecular solid.

Question 3 - Solution

Count shared hydrogen bonds in ideal ice

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Counting donations gives 1200(2)=24001200(2)=2400 bonds. Counting all four contacts per molecule gives 1200(4)/2=24001200(4)/2=2400, because each contact joins two molecules.

(b) Analysis

The O–H covalent connectivity still defines separate H2_2O units. The network connecting those units consists of intermolecular hydrogen bonds rather than continuous covalent bonding between every unit.

Check and interpretation

Donations count each bond once; donations plus acceptances count it twice.