Ionic Solids — Question 8

Section 10-7 · Chemistry pages 1781–1782

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Balance aliovalent substitution with vacancies

A model MX crystal contains 10610^6 anion sites, all filled by X−^-. Its 10610^6 cation sites contain M+^+, D2+^{2+} or vacancies. There are 1000 D ions; assume cation vacancies are the only compensation mechanism.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the required vacancy count and remaining M count.

  2. Verify total charge and explain why replacing M by D without compensation would fail.

Question 8 - Solution

Balance aliovalent substitution with vacancies

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Each D introduces one extra positive charge compared with M, so one missing M is needed per D. There are 1000 vacancies and 106−1000−1000=99800010^6-1000-1000=998000 M ions.

(b) Analysis

Positive charge is 998000+2(1000)=1000000998000+2(1000)=1000000, balancing the anions. With no vacancies, the extra donor charge would remain uncompensated under the stated model.

Check and interpretation

The site budget and charge budget must both close.