Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Distinguish a critical point from a boiling line
Use the supplied hypothetical diagram. Its triple point is (300 K, 2 bar), critical point (500 K, 8 bar), melting line joins (300 K, 2 bar) to (340 K, 10 bar), and liquid–vapor line joins (300 K, 2 bar), (400 K, 4 bar) and (500 K, 8 bar). Treat plotted segments as linear where interpolation is requested. Ignore any additional high-pressure solid phases. Compare states (600 K, 10 bar) and (600 K, 3 bar).
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which state meets both the supplied critical-temperature and critical-pressure criteria for a supercritical fluid?
Explain why compressing at 600 K does not cross a liquid–vapor coexistence line in this diagram.
Question 6 - Solution
Distinguish a critical point from a boiling line
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The state at 600 K and 10 bar exceeds both K and bar. The 3 bar state is above the critical temperature but below critical pressure and is better described here as a gas-like fluid.
(b) Analysis
The liquid–vapor boundary ends at the critical point. At a temperature above it, density can change continuously with pressure without a first-order liquid–vapor transition in the stated range.
Check and interpretation
Exceeding only one critical coordinate does not meet the usual two-condition description of a supercritical state.