Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Report uncertainty honestly near a boundary
Use the supplied hypothetical diagram. Its triple point is (300 K, 2 bar), critical point (500 K, 8 bar), melting line joins (300 K, 2 bar) to (340 K, 10 bar), and liquid–vapor line joins (300 K, 2 bar), (400 K, 4 bar) and (500 K, 8 bar). Treat plotted segments as linear where interpolation is requested. A measurement gives K and bar, with independently possible errors across those intervals.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Can the stable phase be identified uniquely as liquid or vapor from these measurements? Support the answer with allowed state points.
What additional measurement improvement would permit a confident single-phase assignment?
Question 10 - Solution
Report uncertainty honestly near a boundary
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
No. At 400 K, allowed pressure 3.7 bar lies in vapor and 4.3 bar lies in liquid. The uncertainty region crosses the coexistence boundary; an exactly boundary state is also possible.
(b) Analysis
Reduce both coordinate uncertainties enough that the resulting interval lies entirely on one side, or establish the state by an independent phase-sensitive measurement. More decimal places without improved accuracy would not resolve the ambiguity.
Check and interpretation
Uncertainty must be compared with the boundary, not merely with the numerical size of T or P.