The Energies of Solution Formation — Question 6

Section 11-2 · Chemistry pages 1857–1858

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Consider solvent order as well as solute dispersal

When a small, highly charged ion dissolves, it disperses through water but also strongly organizes nearby solvent molecules. A student claims the entropy change must be positive because the ion is more dispersed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the missing contribution in that argument.

  2. Can the sign of the total solution entropy be established from solute dispersal alone?

Question 6 - Solution

Consider solvent order as well as solute dispersal

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The argument omits changes in solvent arrangements and correlations. Strong local hydration can restrict some solvent configurations even while the solute becomes more dispersed.

(b) Analysis

No. Total entropy includes both components and their interactions. One needs the net thermodynamic change; a qualitative dispersal picture for only one component is incomplete.

Check and interpretation

Local solvent ordering does not imply that the whole liquid becomes a rigid crystal.