The Energies of Solution Formation — Question 9

Section 11-2 · Chemistry pages 1863–1864

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Count exchanged contacts in a toy mixing model

A local rearrangement replaces four A–A and four B–B contacts with eight A–B contacts. Assign energies per contact of -5, -3 and -4 arbitrary energy units respectively. Ignore all other changes.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the energy before and after, and the mixing contribution.

  2. If A–B contacts instead had energy -2 units, how would the contribution change?

Question 9 - Solution

Count exchanged contacts in a toy mixing model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Before: 4(−5)+4(−3)=−324(-5)+4(-3)=-32 units. After: 8(−4)=−328(-4)=-32 units, so the change is zero.

(b) Analysis

With weaker unlike contacts, the final energy is 8(−2)=−168(-2)=-16 units, giving +16+16 units for the rearrangement. Mixing then costs energy in this restricted model.

Check and interpretation

Even zero mixing energy does not imply that there is no entropy-driven tendency to mix.