Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Distinguish permeant from retained particles
A membrane passes water and neutral small molecule U, but retains neutral polymer P. Assume U diffuses rapidly enough to equalize before appreciable water transfer, so volumes and polymer concentrations remain effectively unchanged during that interval. Initially L has 0.0200 M P and no U; R has 0.0100 M P plus 0.0100 M U. Assume ideality and equal hydrostatic pressure.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare the initial total particle concentrations.
After U reaches equal concentration on both sides, determine which side has the larger sustained osmotic contribution and the direction favored for water flow.
Question 8 - Solution
Distinguish permeant from retained particles
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Both initially have total particle concentration 0.0200 M, so their ideal solvent chemical potentials initially match at equal pressure.
(b) Analysis
Once U has equal concentrations, its contributions cancel in the difference. L retains 0.0200 M P versus 0.0100 M on R, so L has the larger sustained osmotic contribution and net water flow is favored from R toward L.
Check and interpretation
Equal total concentration at one instant does not ensure sustained osmotic balance across a membrane that passes one solute.