Colligative Properties of Electrolyte Solutions — Question 10

Section 11-7 · Chemistry pages 1965–1966

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Separate concentration effects from fixed particle yield

A 1:1 electrolyte gives effective i values 1.90 at formula molality 0.0200 and 1.75 at 0.200 mol kg−1^{-1}. Use Kf=1.86K_f=1.86 K kg mol−1^{-1}. Treat these as supplied empirical factors for freezing at the respective conditions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find both depressions and their ratio.

  2. Explain why ten times the formula molality does not produce exactly ten times the depression here.

Question 10 - Solution

Separate concentration effects from fixed particle yield

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

At 0.0200, ΔTf=1.90(1.86)(0.0200)=0.0707\Delta T_f=1.90(1.86)(0.0200)=0.0707 K. At 0.200, it is 1.75(1.86)(0.200)=0.6511.75(1.86)(0.200)=0.651 K. The unrounded ratio is 10(1.75/1.90)=9.2110(1.75/1.90)=9.21.

(b) Analysis

The effective factor changes with concentration. The ideal fixed-i proportionality does not apply to these empirical data; the trend alone does not identify a unique association mechanism.

Check and interpretation

Using an empirical i outside its measured concentration or temperature range requires justification.