Colloids — Question 3

Section 11-8 · Chemistry pages 1971–1972

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare diffusion and gravitational settling

For isolated spherical particles in the same liquid at fixed temperature, use D=kBT/(6πηr)D=k_BT/(6\pi\eta r) and terminal settling speed v=2Δρgr2/(9η)v=2\Delta\rho gr^2/(9\eta). Here r is radius, eta viscosity and positive delta-rho the particle-minus-liquid density difference. Compare radii r and 10r with all other parameters fixed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the ratios of diffusion coefficient and settling speed for large versus small particles.

  2. For the dimensionless competition measure S=vr/DS=vr/D, find its size scaling and explain the implication.

Question 3 - Solution

Compare diffusion and gravitational settling

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

D10r/Dr=1/10D_{10r}/D_r=1/10 and v10r/vr=100v_{10r}/v_r=100. Larger particles diffuse more slowly and settle faster in these models.

(b) Analysis

S∝r2r/(1/r)=r4S\propto r^2r/(1/r)=r^4, so S10r/Sr=104S_{10r}/S_r=10^4. Gravitational drift becomes much more important relative to diffusion over one particle radius as size grows.

Check and interpretation

Brownian motion is thermal random motion, not a force that guarantees every colloid can never settle.