Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Design a meaningful speed comparison
Two batches produce 0.0100 mol P in their first minute. Batch X has volume 0.100 L, batch Y 0.500 L. A researcher claims their intrinsic reaction kinetics are identical.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare their average volumetric P formation rates.
List the controls and further observations required to test the intrinsic-kinetics claim.
Question 10 - Solution
Design a meaningful speed comparison
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
X gives 0.100 M min and Y 0.0200 M min, a factor of five apart despite equal molar production.
(b) Analysis
Compare at the same temperature, composition, concentration, mixing and catalyst conditions; measure a time trace and calibrated local rates. Equal amount production alone cannot determine a common rate law or rate constant.
Check and interpretation
Rate comparisons must specify whether the quantity is per batch, per volume or per catalyst amount.