Rate Laws: An Introduction — Question 5

Section 12-2 · Chemistry pages 2015–2016

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Do not infer a rate law from an overall equation

The overall reaction is 2A+B→P2A+B\to P. A student writes r=k[A]2[B]r=k[A]^2[B] solely from that equation. Another proposes r=k[A][B]r=k[A][B]. No kinetic data or elementary-step claim is provided.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain whether either law is established.

  2. Describe a controlled measurement that distinguishes their dependence on A.

Question 5 - Solution

Do not infer a rate law from an overall equation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Neither is established by an overall balanced equation. Stoichiometry fixes net consumption ratios, but a multistep pathway can produce different empirical concentration dependence.

(b) Analysis

At fixed B, temperature and other conditions, double initial A and compare initial rates. The first proposed law predicts a factor of four; the second predicts a factor of two.

Check and interpretation

Concentration powers follow molecularity directly only for a stated elementary step under its mass-action model.