Determining the Form of the Rate Law — Question 5

Section 12-3 · Chemistry pages 2035–2036

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Detect an unidentifiable experimental design

Every run in a study has [A] = [B]. Doubling both concentrations increases rate fourfold. The model is r=k[A]m[B]nr=k[A]^m[B]^n.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. State what is and is not determined about m and n.

  2. Propose one additional run that distinguishes (m,n) = (2,0) from (1,1).

Question 5 - Solution

Detect an unidentifiable experimental design

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The data imply 2m+n=42^{m+n}=4, hence m+n = 2, but cannot separate m from n. Both proposed pairs fit, as do other pairs with the same sum.

(b) Analysis

Double A while keeping B fixed relative to a reference run. The (2,0) model predicts fourfold rate; the (1,1) model predicts twofold rate.

Check and interpretation

More repeated points along the same [A] = [B] line improve precision but do not remove this structural ambiguity.