Rate Laws: A Summary — Question 2

Section 12-5 · Chemistry pages 2069–2070

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Compare models with the same initial slope

Model F has −d[A]/dt=0.100[A]-d[A]/dt=0.100[A] and model S has −d[A]/dt=0.500[A]2-d[A]/dt=0.500[A]^2, using M and s. Both start at 0.200 M. Their integrated forms are AF=0.200e−0.100tA_F=0.200e^{-0.100t} and AS=0.200/(1+0.100t)A_S=0.200/(1+0.100t).

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Verify equal initial disappearance rates and calculate both concentrations at 10.0 s.

  2. Explain why one initial slope cannot determine reaction order.

Question 2 - Solution

Compare models with the same initial slope

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both initial rates are 0.0200 M s−1^{-1}. At 10.0 s, AF=0.0736A_F=0.0736 M and AS=0.100A_S=0.100 M.

(b) Analysis

Different laws can intersect at one initial concentration and share a tangent there. Measurements over changing concentration, or additional initial concentrations, reveal their different dependence.

Check and interpretation

The graph shows model predictions, not measured evidence selecting one model.