Rate Laws: A Summary — Question 6

Section 12-5 · Chemistry pages 2077–2078

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Find where two reaction speeds cross

At one temperature, process X has disappearance rate vX=0.0200[A]v_X=0.0200[A] with k in s−1^{-1}, and process Y has vY=0.200[A]2v_Y=0.200[A]^2 with k in M−1^{-1} s−1^{-1}. Compare them at the same A concentration.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the positive concentration at which the rates are equal.

  2. Which is faster at 0.0200 M and at 0.500 M? Explain why comparing bare k values is misleading.

Question 6 - Solution

Find where two reaction speeds cross

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

0.0200[A]=0.200[A]20.0200[A]=0.200[A]^2 gives [A] = 0.100 M for positive A.

(b) Analysis

At 0.0200 M, X gives 0.000400 and Y 0.0000800 M s−1^{-1}, so X is faster. At 0.500 M, X gives 0.0100 and Y 0.0500 M s−1^{-1}, so Y is faster. Their k values have different dimensions and concentration dependencies.

Check and interpretation

Both rates also vanish at zero A, but that trivial equality does not mark the positive-concentration crossover.