Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Recognize that a matching rate law is not proof
Two proposed mechanisms predict the same empirical law over the tested range. One has a directly reacting A/B pair; the other includes a short-lived intermediate whose elimination yields the same law.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain what agreement with the rate law establishes.
Propose two additional types of evidence that could discriminate between the proposals.
Question 7 - Solution
Recognize that a matching rate law is not proof
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Agreement shows kinetic consistency in that regime, not uniqueness. Different microscopic pathways can yield the same observable concentration dependence.
(b) Analysis
Time-resolved detection or trapping of a predicted intermediate can test its existence. Isotope-label tracing or changing conditions to a regime where the mechanisms predict different dependencies can test pathway details. Controls must exclude artifacts and inactive side species.
Check and interpretation
Failure to detect a very short-lived intermediate is not by itself proof that it is absent.