Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Use an isotopic tracer to test dynamic exchange
A closed mixture has stable bulk concentrations. A tiny tracer amount of isotopically labeled A is introduced without measurably changing composition. Assume labeling negligibly changes the kinetics or equilibrium. Labeled B subsequently appears.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain what the tracer observation demonstrates.
State a control needed before attributing labeled B to the reversible reaction.
Question 7 - Solution
Use an isotopic tracer to test dynamic exchange
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The label moved from A into B while bulk composition remained nearly constant, demonstrating molecular conversion despite the apparently stationary mixture.
(b) Analysis
Check that labeled B was not present as an impurity, that the detector distinguishes the species, and that the label cannot exchange through a separate pathway. The tracer alone does not prove the forward and reverse rates are equal without the bulk equilibrium evidence.
Check and interpretation
The negligible-perturbation and negligible-isotope-effect assumptions are explicit.