Solving Equilibrium Problems — Question 5

Section 13-6 · Chemistry pages 2255–2256

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Reject an unjustified small-change approximation

For ideal A⇌B+CA\rightleftharpoons B+C, initial [A] = 0.0100 M and products are absent. K = 0.00100 using concentration ratios to 1 M. The exact numerical equation is x2/(0.0100−x)=0.00100x^2/(0.0100-x)=0.00100.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the small-change estimate and test it against the initial concentration.

  2. Find the physical exact root and quantify the relative overestimate in x.

Question 5 - Solution

Reject an unjustified small-change approximation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The estimate is x≈0.00100(0.0100)=0.003162x\approx\sqrt{0.00100(0.0100)}=0.003162 M, or 31.6 percent of initial A. Neglecting this change in the denominator is inappropriate.

(b) Analysis

Solve x2+0.00100x−0.0000100=0x^2+0.00100x-0.0000100=0 to obtain x = 0.00270156 M. The estimate overstates x by (0.00316228/0.00270156−1)100=17.1(0.00316228/0.00270156-1)100=17.1 percent.

Check and interpretation

The negative root is excluded; the accepted positive root is below the initial A concentration.