The Nature of Acids and Bases — Question 9

Section 14-1 · Chemistry pages 2303–2304

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Track a labeled proton without changing the definition

In a hypothetical single event, deuterated acid DA transfers D+D^+ to H2OH_2O, producing A−A^- and H2DO+H_2DO^+. D is the hydrogen isotope with one neutron. Ignore later isotope exchange.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the donor, acceptor and conjugate pairs.

  2. Explain whether isotope labeling changes the acid–base classification.

Question 9 - Solution

Track a labeled proton without changing the definition

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

DA is donor and water acceptor. The isotope-resolved pairs are DA/A−DA/A^- and H2DO+/H2OH_2DO^+/H_2O, differing by one deuteron.

(b) Analysis

The event still transfers a hydrogen nucleus. Isotope substitution may alter rates or equilibria, so identical numerical constants must not be assumed; it does not change donor versus acceptor classification.

Check and interpretation

The label traces the transferred nucleus without requiring all hydrogen atoms to remain fixed in later events.