The Lewis Acid–Base Model — Question 2

Section 14-11 · Chemistry pages 2489–2490

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Calculate formal charges after coordinate-bond formation

In the single-bond Lewis contributor for H3N−BF3H_3N-BF_3, nitrogen has four bonds and no lone pair; boron also has four bonds. Use formal charge = valence electrons minus nonbonding electrons minus half the bonding electrons.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find formal charges on N and B and total adduct charge.

  2. Explain why these formal charges do not contradict the reactant acid/base roles.

Question 2 - Solution

Calculate formal charges after coordinate-bond formation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

N has 5−0−8/2=+15-0-8/2=+1; B has 3−0−8/2=−13-0-8/2=-1. Each F and H is formally neutral, so the adduct is neutral overall.

(b) Analysis

Formal charges result from equal bond-electron assignment in a Lewis contributor. The donor was nitrogen and the acceptor boron during bond formation; the bookkeeping charges do not reverse that history or equal measured partial charges.

Check and interpretation

A coordinate bond is a shared bond once formed; formal charge is not oxidation state.