The Lewis Acid–Base Model — Question 10

Section 14-11 · Chemistry pages 2505–2506

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Choose the model supported by the observation

A neutral donor molecule D binds an electron-deficient molecule A in dry solvent to form AD. No hydrogen atoms are present in either molecule. The adduct is detected spectroscopically.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain which acid–base model directly describes the event.

  2. Can the adduct observation alone predict the pH of a hypothetical aqueous mixture? State missing information.

Question 10 - Solution

Choose the model supported by the observation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The Lewis model describes donation of an electron pair from D to A. A proton-transfer description cannot apply to this hydrogen-free adduct event.

(b) Analysis

No. One would need aqueous stability, hydrolysis and proton-transfer equilibria, concentrations and activity conditions. Lewis acidity in an organic solvent does not directly assign an aqueous pH.

Check and interpretation

Classify the actual event and medium rather than assuming every acid must generate hydronium in every situation.