Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Audit a spectator-ion argument
Assume ideal dilute aqueous behavior at 25 C, , and concentrations in mol L unless stated otherwise. A student claims all positively charged ions make water acidic and all negatively charged ions make it basic. Compare Na, NH, Cl and F.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Give a counterexample to each universal claim.
State a chemically useful replacement rule.
Question 10 - Solution
Audit a spectator-ion argument
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Na does not appreciably acidify water in this model; Cl does not appreciably accept protons from water. Their signs alone do not imply reactive acid–base behavior.
(b) Analysis
Identify accessible proton-transfer or hydrated-ion hydrolysis equilibria and their constants. NH can donate; F can accept; Na and Cl are effectively spectators under ordinary dilute conditions.
Check and interpretation
Electrical neutrality of the whole solution is compatible with either acidic or basic pH.